During the summer transfer window, Harvey Elliott was a player in demand. The creative forward had claimed the Player of the Tournament award at the 2025 U21 Euros having helped England retain their crown.
By Sam McGuire
Elliott netted in the quarter-final win over Spain, was the match-winner against the Netherlands in the semi-final and scored the opener against Germany in the final.
Having struggled to convince Arne Slot that he was an option for Liverpool during their title success last term, a move away from Anfield appeared to be a formality. Newcastle United, Tottenham Hotspur, RB Leipzig and Fulham were all linked with the 22-year-old. On deadline day, though, a move to Aston Villa materialised out of nowhere. It was an initial loan move with an obligation to buy for £35million if the versatile midfielder appeared in a set number of matches, reported to be 10.
At a glance, it seemed like a bargain buy for Unai Emery’s side. Elliott, despite his tender years, was closing in on 100 Premier League appearances for Liverpool. He had experience in the Champions League and could play a variety of positions. For context, Nick Woltemade finished as the top scorer at the U21 Euros and he moved to Newcastle for an initial £65million.
Villa had the opportunity to sign the best player at the tournament for half the price.

Yet here we are in January and Elliott finds himself in purgatory.
He’s featured in just four Premier League matches for Villa this term and has a grand total of 97 minutes to his name since the switch to Villa Park. Emery has made it clear. He doesn’t intend to make Elliott’s move a permanent one meaning he can’t play the England Under-21 international so as to avoid paying the £35million fee.
The Villa boss acknowledged this at the start of the year.
“The problem we have with Harvey is that this year he is on loan, and in case he plays matches we must buy him,” said Emery. “We decided two months ago that we are not convinced to sign him, spending the money we would need to sign him.
“This is the only issue. He is training every day, always every day with very good behaviour and to help us in training sessions. This is not something good for him and good for us, but this is football and sometimes we must take some decisions which are not good for everyone.”
According to reports, Villa can’t cut short the loan without having to pay a fee to Liverpool. To further complicate matters, having already played for two clubs this season, Elliott can’t move to another European club this month. He can, however, move to MLS, with Charlotte FC allegedly keen on the left-footer. Elliott, though, isn’t wanting to move to the States at this stage of his career.
At a glance, his options are limited. When asked about Elliott ahead of the Arsenal match, Slot distanced himself from the player, saying: “He’s an Aston Villa player. So if you want to ask things about an Aston Villa player, you should ask Unai Emery.”
Villa don’t want him. Liverpool, seemingly, don’t want him back.

But the reigning champions could do with him right now. The Reds are struggling despite currently being on an eight-match unbeaten run in the Premier League. However, this has been made up of four wins and four draws. Slot’s side have dropped points against Leeds (twice), Sunderland and Fulham while narrowly beating the likes of Spurs, West Ham, Brighton and Wolves during this period.
Liverpool need a spark in attack, despite spending near £300million on attackers during the summer. Alexander Isak moved for £125million, Florian Wirtz cost £100million and Hugo Ekitike cost an initial £69million. Isak is out with a broken leg, Wirtz has just two league goals to his name and Ekitike is now struggling for fitness having played a lot of football due to the absence of the No. 9. Cody Gakpo has just returned from injury while Mohamed Salah is away at AFCON and there are still question marks over his future with the club following his blockbuster interview following the draw with Leeds.
At the time of writing, the Reds rank eighth for Expected Goals in the English top-flight. We’re 20 games into the season and Slot’s side have a goal difference of plus four. Whatever the reason for it, the Reds are struggling in the final third. The bench looks deprived of attacking talent and Elliott could well play a key role in getting this team into the Champions League next term.
Last season, in limited minutes, he had an xG per 90 average of 0.44 and an Expected Assists average of 0.16. He was creating 2.5 chances per 90 too in the Premier League. Liverpool are struggling against low blocks, why not look to give Elliott, someone who is brilliant technically and has the vision to spot a pass, the opportunity to pull some strings for the new signings?
A return to Liverpool suits everyone right now. Elliott gets more opportunities to play football ahead of a permanent move away in the summer. Villa free up a space in their squad and avoid having to sign a player they don’t want. And the Reds add depth to their team.
(Cover image from IMAGO)
You can follow every Liverpool game with FotMob this season – featuring deep stats coverage, xG, and player ratings. Download the free app here.




























