Preview: City and United meet in the Community Shield

After a summer full of international football, the 2024/25 season is already set to get underway in England. As is tradition, the Community Shield will start proceedings by pitting Premier League winners Manchester City against FA Cup holders Manchester United.


By Neel Shelat


New Names, Same Issues For United?

Despite their FA Cup triumph, Manchester United had a big decision to make in the summer regarding head coach Erik ten Hag. An eighth-placed finish in the league and some of the worst underlying defensive numbers not just in England but across Europe’s top five leagues were big causes for concern, but the new management brought in by INEOS’ takeover decided to stick with the Dutchman and bring him reinforcements in the transfer window.

The signing of Leny Yoro as well as the various other names they have been linked to suggest that United are attempting a defensive renovation, but their performances and results in recent friendlies have seemingly reinforced the idea that the problems go beyond personnel and down to a tactical level.

The injury issues that plagued the Red Devils last season have not gone away either, as Yoro had to undergo surgery very soon after joining, Rasmus Højlund and Tyrell Malacia are out for the foreseeable future, while Harry Maguire and Victor Lindelöf are both doubtful for this match.

Manchester Derby results, 2023/24 season

Stability Promises Success For City

On the other side of Manchester, City have enjoyed an incredibly peaceful window. The only signing they have made has been Sávio from sister club Troyes, so their expenditure this summer is by far the lowest since the Abu Dhabi-led takeover. They are yet to announce any major departures either, although that may soon change with Julián Álvarez reportedly set to join Atlético Madrid. Even then, their squad will be almost identical to the one that won the Premier League last season.

The most important transfer news for City this season will be about Pep Guardiola’s contract, which expires next summer. Regardless of whether or not he stays further, they look primed for success in 2024/25 at least.

Can Ortega Stake A Claim To A Starting Spot?

There was a good deal of speculation around Ederson and a potential move to Saudi Arabia this summer, but it looks like he will be staying for now. The Brazilian goalkeeper’s fitness is a doubt for this game, so Stefan Ortega might get a chance to continue making his case to become City’s number one. He might not have the same long passing range, but he is about as comfortable with the ball at his feet and potentially a more composed shot-stopper.

Ortega player traits


(Cover image from IMAGO)


You can follow every game from top flight game from England live with FotMob — featuring deep stats coverage, xG, and player ratings. Download the free app here.